A dramatic development: Aaron Spencer, a father from Lonoke County, Arkansas, is now campaigning to become sheriff — even as he faces second-degree murder charges for the killing of Michael Fosler, 67. The shooting occurred after Spencer reportedly found Fosler alone in a vehicle with Spencer’s then-14-year-old daughter. Spencer contends the justice system “failed” his family and says his bid for office is a bid for trust.
What Happened: The Shooting & the Case
The Incident
- On October 2024, local authorities in Lonoke County responded to a missing child report. Spencer claimed that while searching, he found his teenage daughter in a car with Michael Fosler.
- Spencer allegedly forced Fosler’s vehicle off the road, confronted him, and shot him during a physical altercation. Fosler was pronounced dead at the scene.
- At the time, Fosler was reportedly out on bond facing multiple charges, including internet stalking a child and sexual assault, related to Spencer’s daughter.
Legal Status & Timeline
- Spencer was arrested and charged with second-degree murder.
- A pre-trial hearing is set for December 16, 2025, and the trial is slated to begin January 26, 2026.
- Local media confirm the case remains ongoing and the investigation is active.
Spencer’s Campaign for Sheriff
- Despite the serious charges, Spencer publicly launched a campaign for Lonoke County Sheriff via a video posted on Facebook.
- In the video, Spencer framed his candidacy as a response to perceived failures in the legal system, especially in cases involving victims who feel unprotected.
- He introduced himself as a combat veteran, contractor, and farmer, describing the campaign as something bigger than himself — “about restoring trust.”
- The campaign attracted significant attention online — the video had been viewed hundreds of thousands of times by the time of reporting.
Public Reaction & Complexity
- Spencer’s wife has publicly defended his actions, calling him a “hero” and criticizing the decision to charge him with murder. She has also claimed their daughter was groomed and that Fosler violated protective orders.
- Some local officials emphasize that regardless of motive, a homicide must be fully investigated to determine whether it was justifiable.
- The case raises thorny questions about vigilantism, parent protection vs. due process, and how communities respond when they feel the justice system fails.
