Timothy Bohler—a 31-year-old Bronx resident with a lengthy criminal record—is now charged in connection with a fatal hit-and-run in Queens that killed a 52-year-old cancer survivor. These charges come while he remains incarcerated for a brutal machete attack earlier this year. The case raises serious questions about repeat offenders and the criminal justice system.
Criminal History & Prior Violence
- Bohler reportedly has 45 prior arrests spanning assault, weapon charges, domestic violence, and more.
- In early 2025, he was arrested for a machete assault in the Bronx, during which he allegedly severed four fingers of an MTA worker, Tayquon Young, and threatened continued violence.
- While jailed on that case, authorities say he assaulted a corrections officer at Rikers Island using pepper spray that he procured illicitly.
This history has fueled public concern over how someone with such a record remained free long enough to commit additional crimes.
The Hit-and-Run Case
Incident & Victim
- Date & Location: March 22, 2024, in Queens (Richmond Hill area)
- Victim: Lelawattie Narine, age 52, had recently completed cancer treatment.
- Reports suggest Bohler was driving a motorcycle when Narine was struck at an intersection.
- Narine was transported to Jamaica Hospital in critical condition and died within weeks.
Identification Challenge
Because Narine had no ID or personal items with her, she was initially treated as a “Jane Doe.” Her identity was later confirmed thanks to items discovered by her son, including a wig.
Charges
Bohler now faces:
- Leaving the scene of an accident resulting in death
- Operating a vehicle without a license
- Other related traffic and criminal violations
Reaction & Wider Implications
- Narine’s son has publicly questioned how a person with dozens of arrests can remain active, emphasizing the need for accountability.
- Tayquon Young’s family has expressed frustration, hoping this time the system holds Bohler responsible.
- The case has intensified debate around bail reform, judicial oversight, and how the system handles violent repeat offenders.
Conclusion
This case illustrates a troubling pattern: alleged violent offenders slipping through systemic cracks until tragedy occurs. As Bohler faces these new charges, many will be watching to see whether the legal system delivers justice—or once again, fails the victims.
