The Parents Gave Me One Rule When I Babysat: “Don’t Answer the Upstairs Phone.” It Wasn’t Even Plugged In. At 9:47 p.m., It Rang.

⏱ 5 min read

“There’s a phone in the upstairs hallway. If it rings, don’t answer it.”

Mr. Pemberton said it while he was fixing his tie.

I laughed. I thought it was a joke.

Nobody laughed with me.

Two hours later, I found out the phone wasn’t connected to anything.

At 9:47 p.m., it rang anyway.


My name is Emma. I was sixteen that October, and I lived in Westerville, Ohio.

The Pemberton house sat at the end of Larchmont Court. A tall Victorian with a wraparound porch and a round turret on top. I’d biked past it a hundred times.

I’d never been inside until Mrs. Pemberton hired me to babysit.

“Lucas is six,” she said, putting on her earrings in the front hall. “He’s had dinner and a bath. Bedtime is eight. He’ll ask for one more story. Say yes once.”

Then Mr. Pemberton came down the stairs and gave me the rule about the phone.

I noticed Mrs. Pemberton suddenly got very busy with her purse.

“Is it, like, a wrong number thing?” I asked.

“Something like that,” he said. “We’ll be home by eleven.”

The big front door clicked shut.

And I was alone in that house with a six-year-old and a rule that made no sense.


Lucas was easy. Solemn little boy with huge glasses. He showed me his rock collection and explained the difference between igneous and sedimentary for twenty minutes.

We built a blanket fort. We ate popcorn. At eight, I read him a book about a bear who couldn’t sleep. Then one more.

He was asleep before the end.

I stepped out into the upstairs hallway.

And I saw the phone.


It sat on a narrow wooden table under the window at the end of the hall.

An old rotary phone. Heavy. Cream-colored. The kind with a dial you spin with your finger.

A coiled cord ran from the back of it down into the wall.

I went closer, mostly out of curiosity.

That’s when I saw the jack.

The phone jack in the baseboard was painted over. Thick, glossy white paint. Layers of it. Sealed completely shut.

Whatever that phone was connected to, it hadn’t been connected to anything in a very, very long time.

I let out a breath and laughed at myself.

A dead phone. Old house. Family joke to scare the babysitter.

I went downstairs and texted my best friend Priya.

babysitting at the creepy turret house lol. parents said don’t answer the upstairs phone. it’s not even plugged in 💀

Priya texted back in two seconds.

EMMA. do NOT go back up there. this is literally how every horror movie starts.

I sent her a skull emoji and turned on Netflix.


At 9:47 p.m., the upstairs phone rang.

Not a modern ring. A bell. A real metal bell, loud and shrill and old-fashioned. It went through the house like an ice pick.

BRRRRING.

I froze on the couch with the remote in my hand.

BRRRRING.

It couldn’t be ringing. I had seen the jack. I had seen the paint.

A Victorian house with a turret at night and a figure in the turret window

BRRRRING.

Then, from upstairs, small and sleepy:

“Emma? The phone’s ringing.”

Lucas.

I was up the stairs before I could think.

He was standing in his doorway in dinosaur pajamas, rubbing his eyes, glasses crooked.

At the end of the hall, the cream-colored phone shrieked again. The whole thing was shaking on the little table.

“Back to bed, buddy,” I said. My voice was shaking. “It’s just a wrong number.”

Lucas shook his head.

“It’s not a wrong number,” he said, completely serious. “It’s for you. It’s always for the babysitter.”


I looked down at him.

“What do you mean, always?”

“Mommy and Daddy never answer it,” he said. “But the babysitters do. The lady on the phone asks them to come help her.”

He yawned.

“And then they go.”

BRRRRING.

“Go where?” I whispered.

Lucas pointed past the phone. Past the window. To the narrow door at the very end of the hall.

The one I’d thought was a linen closet.

The one that led up into the turret.

“Up,” he said.

“Mrs. Henley went. And Chloe. And the one before Chloe. I don’t remember her name.”

BRRRRING.


I did not answer the phone.

And I’m still proud of what I did instead.

I picked up Lucas. All forty pounds of him. I carried him down the stairs and straight out the front door onto the porch in his socks.

I called his parents. Then my mom. Then, because my hands wouldn’t stop shaking, I called 911.

The phone rang upstairs the entire time.

I counted.

Forty-one rings.

Then it stopped.


The police found nothing. Of course they found nothing.

The turret room was empty. Just dust and an old wicker rocking chair facing the window.

The officer was kind about it. Old houses make strange noises, he said. Old wiring. Pipes. Overactive imaginations.

The Pembertons came racing home at 10:30. My mom wrapped me in a blanket in the front seat of our car.

Then there was a knock on the car window.

It was Mrs. Pemberton. Her face was gray in the streetlight.

“You didn’t answer it,” she said. “You didn’t go up.”

“No,” I said.

She closed her eyes.

“Thank you,” she whispered. “Thank you. You’re the first one who didn’t.”


The next day, I went to the Westerville Public Library and asked for the historical society’s newspaper archive.

It took me an hour.

October 1952. Local girl, 16, vanishes while babysitting on Larchmont Court.

Her name was Margaret Ames.

According to the police report, she received a phone call on the upstairs line that evening. The family’s little boy saw her walk up the turret stairs.

She was never seen again.

The case was never solved.

And there was one more thing in that article. One line I’ve never been able to forget.

The child told police the caller was “a lady who needed help.”


The Pembertons put the house up for sale that spring.

I biked past it once in April. There was a FOR SALE sign on the lawn.

And high up in the turret window, I saw the curtain move.

I didn’t stop.

I never babysat on Larchmont Court again.

But some nights, when my phone buzzes on the nightstand in the dark, I lie very still and count the rings before I look to see who it is.

THE END

Some rules sound silly until you understand why they exist. Always listen when someone says “don’t.”

Would you have answered the phone? Be honest. Tell us in the comments.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *